I love Tony Brown's Journal. Not always accurate...but always entertaining.
This isn't new. It's as old as hip hop itself.
But, for the first time, young people, not just old outsiders, are starting to question if rabid materialism provides enough spiritual nutrition to create a good person.
(skip past Tony's droning. Thomas starts talking after about 3 minutes)
Part 1:
Part 2:
Even
Gawker called out Jay Z recently though moreso for a concern about the purity of the art form, which me and
Christian Lander totally disagree with them on. Yet they do touch on his glorification of money as a larger ill. The secret is out. You can listen to his music, he and his peers, all day long and not learn a damn thing.
Fair or not, Jigga has become the poster child for hip hop. And as we see the young blacks in our cities continue on a path of self-destruction, again something that is WAY OLDER than hip hop...one wonders if those with the largest megaphones aimed at the youth could be using them for the glorification of a life well led and fulfilled...even if it meant not being "drug money rich".
An old issue. A complicated issue. But we should never stop trying to figure this one out.
My personal take is that our music suffers from a lack of balance. There's no more yang. Just tons of bling and Ying. Our shit is all Sith no Jedi. We need both. Even though the sith do make better records. The economics make it impossible for the Jedi to even get signed or stay positive. It is what it is.
Hip hip is now run by a bunch of out of touch old dudes. They no longer just want money, they want an empire. They exploit their legitimately tough pasts at the expense of our future.
It's not Jay Z's fault. But he ain't helping either.
The silver lining though is that history repeats itself. When some cultural behemoth gets too big it tends to get shunned. More and more young people are getting off of Facebook. And just like grunge obliterated Hollywood glam rock in the early 90's*...
...so too could some new musical interpretation come along and wipe hip hop off the charts.
It's happened before.
Shit... it might even be a different form of hip hop that does it.
---
*It was so great to see grunge come along. it's one of the few cultural movements I got to actually witness. As soon as Smells Like Teen Spirit hit the streets...it's like you couldn't listen to guns and roses; their music was nauseating compared to that of STP, Pearl Jam, Alice In Chains and others.